Creamy Protein Cheesecake (2024)

Updated: Sep 16, 2022 · Published: Dec 8, 2013 · By Andréa Marchese · This post may contain affiliate links · 8 Comments

This recipe for Creamy Protein Cheesecake used to be called Aunt Chubby’s Protein Cheesecake. Yes, Aunt Chubby. My mom had an aunt whose name was Mary. But when she was little, there were too many Marys in the family. So she was called Chubby Mary. And then eventually, just Chubby. I think she had some friends who called her Mary (I hope), but she remained Chubby to us for her entire adult life. (That's what is great about family stories - you just can’t make this stuff up!)

Anyway, every holiday Aunt Chubby would make an amazing cheesecake. So creamy and so delicious. When she passed away, I asked for her recipes so I could carry on the tradition.

When I started protein baking and came across some cheesecake recipes, I knew I would want a protein cheesecake that tasted as close as possible to Aunt Chubby’s recipe. So I used her recipe as a guide. I made a few substitutions, added some protein powder, and it worked!

I used nonfat Greek yogurt instead of the sour cream, Neufchâtelcheese instead of cream cheese, and agave instead of sugar. I’m also making a smaller cheesecake here, so I halved the recipe.

If you’re new to baking, you might want to try an easier recipe first. There are a couple of important factors in cheesecake baking that can make it intimidating: the water bath and the bake time.

I come from a family of bakers, and they’ll all say the same thing when it comes to baking a cheesecake at home: you need a water bath to get the heat distributed evenly. Aunt Chubby’s Protein Cheesecake is no different. This just means that instead of placing the springform pan directly on the oven rack, you’ll place it in a pan of water on the oven rack. About an inch of water should be enough.

You’ll notice I have some foil around the pan, as well. This is just to prevent water from leaking into the cheesecake. Since we are lining the bottom of the pan with parchment, the seal on the springform might not be watertight.

It’s also important to get the timing right, and this may take a few tries for your particular oven. (No worries, though. All of your trial cheesecakes will be delicious! The texture just might be off a little.) Cheesecake shouldn’t look well-done on the outside. That would mean it is overcooked, and you’ll get more of a spongy cake texture than the creamy cheesecake texture we’re going for. So when you turn the oven off, the middle of your cheesecake should still feel a little jiggly. The cake will continue to set as it cools, so be sure to let it cool completely (overnight, ideally) before serving.

The bake times in the recipe below follow a different scheme, one that works well for this modified recipe.

Although Aunt Chubby had no interest in bodybuilding, I think she’d be very impressed with this high-protein version of her cheesecake. Well, as long as it didn’t crack. I'm still working on that.

Notes:

Neufchâtelcheese is marketed as “⅓ less fat than cream cheese” and can be found in most supermarkets (in the US, at least). I don’t use fat-free cream cheese because of all the additional ingredients they throw in there. I would rather make room in my macros for some fat.

🥣 Recipe